Vote integrity
Every ranking on Whatsup comes from votes. This page states exactly how votes become scores, what we do to keep them honest and what businesses can and cannot do.
How a score is calculated
Each place has a score from 0 to 100 in every list it appears in. The score is the Wilson score lower bound of its share of upvotes at 95% confidence, multiplied by 100. In plain terms: it is the lowest upvote share we can be 95% confident the place really has, given how many votes it has received.
With p as the share of upvotes, n as the number of votes and z = 1.96:
score = 100 × (p + z²/2n − z × √((p(1 − p) + z²/4n) / n)) / (1 + z²/n)
This rewards a long record over a lucky start. A place with 3 upvotes and no downvotes scores 44. A place with 300 upvotes and 20 downvotes scores 91.
Ties are broken by total votes, then alphabetically by name.
When lists and places are ranked
- A list is ranked once it has 50 counted votes across its places. Some categories may set a different number, shown on the list. Below that, the list says it is still gathering votes and is kept out of search engines.
- A place holds a rank once it has 5 counted votes in that list. Until then it is shown under “Not ranked yet” and can still be voted on.
- The Trending view orders ranked places by votes in the last 7 days. It does not change anyone’s rank.
- Lists update within a minute of a vote.
Businesses with several locations
A business with more than one location in a city is a single entry on that city’s lists, however many locations it has. Its place on a list comes from votes cast on the business. Each location can be voted on separately on the business’s page, where the locations are ranked against each other once they have 20 counted votes between them. A vote on a location never changes where the business stands on a city list, so a business with twenty locations has no more say there than a business with one.
One person, one vote
- Voting needs an account with a verified email address. There is no anonymous voting.
- Each account has one vote per place in each list. You can change it or undo it at any time.
- Accounts are limited to 30 vote actions an hour and 200 a day.
How we handle suspicious votes
- New accounts count for less. Votes from an account count at 50% until the account is 7 days old and has cast 10 votes. After that all of its votes count in full.
- Clusters are held. We hold votes when several accounts vote on the same place from one connection or one browser, when a brand-new account votes in a rapid burst, or when a wave of new accounts votes the same way on one place within an hour.
- Held is not deleted. A held vote is kept out of the score until a moderator reviews it. It is then either counted or removed. Every decision is logged.
To spot clusters we store a keyed hash of the voter’s IP address and of a random browser identifier. We do not store the raw values. See the privacy policy.
What businesses can and cannot do
- Businesses cannot pay to change votes or rank. There is no paid placement in any ranked list. If sponsored content ever appears on the site it will be labelled and shown apart from the rankings.
- An owner can claim a listing for free and show a “Verified by owner” badge. Claiming does not change votes or rank.
- Owners cannot vote on a business they have claimed. If an owner voted before claiming, that vote is removed.
- Downvotes are not removed at a business’s request. Factual errors (a wrong address, a closure, a duplicate listing) can be reported from the listing and are corrected by a moderator.
- We never offer anything in exchange for a vote in a particular direction, and businesses may not either. See the community guidelines.
Recommendations from local guides
Next to a place you may see “Recommended by” with the names of local guides, newsletters and community threads that recommend it, each linked to its page. We record only that a page names the place, never its text. Recommendations do not count towards a score or a rank. They are used for one thing: among places that hold no rank yet and have the same number of votes, those recommended by more pages are listed first, so a new list starts with the places people already talk about. One vote moves a place ahead of any number of recommendations.
Outside data shown next to votes
Listings can also show facts from outside sources, such as a health inspection result, the year a business opened, a rating from another site or a summary of public reviews. These never affect a score or rank. Each one names its source, and we only show a value for as long as that source’s terms allow.
| Source | Terms we apply |
|---|---|
| Public Health, Seattle & King County | King County open data (public record) |
| City of Seattle business licence records | City of Seattle open data (public record) |
| Yelp | Yelp API terms: display only, with attribution; stored content limited to 24 hours |
| Google Maps Platform terms: shown with the Google logo and a link to Google Maps; kept for at most 24 hours | |
| Review synopsis | Generated from review text supplied by cleared sources |
Open data
Every ranked list can be downloaded as a CSV file from the list page. The file contains the ranks, scores and vote counts shown on the page, so anyone can check our arithmetic.
